- Kitchen & Dining
- Walls & Floors
- Doors & Windows
Thankyou for registering on ZingyHomes.We have sent you a verification email. Please click on the link mentioned in the email to activate your account and start using the site!
As a member, you get exclusive offers, discounts, sneak previews, space planner and members only rewards and privileges.
You already have an account? Great! Sign In
Remind me later
Sign In to ZingyHomes
The Importance of Design competitionsBy Design Plus
Architecture Tweet 0 Comment(s)
Architectural Competitions have the possibility to enrich the Design Environment, strengthen culture and impart knowledge. They are opportunities to make leaps in architectural thinking and go beyond what exists. They are moments in history that enable us to contemplate on our past, present and future, on subjects that are beyond architecture itself. “Every competition remains a world of possibilities: an intermediary space-time locus for the search for excellence in architecture. In some ways, competition projects function like utopias” 1
The history of competitions can be traced back to either the mythical competitions of the construction of the Acropolis2 or a more accurately to the French Revolution, where several competitions were put to a more political and democratic use. “During the period of the revolution, no less than 207 projects with architectural program were designed via competitions spanning triumphal arches, covered arenas, temples of equality and other public buildings.”3 However, the merits and problems with architectural competitions to this date remain identical. The deliberations of concern span centuries - from the history mentioned to the more modern examples of Parc de la Villette or more recently Helsinki Guggenheim or even more closer to home, like the Nalanda University or The Sayli International Sports Complex.
1. Judgement Paradox – For any competition it is paramount that the judgement is not only transparent and fair but also is by an educated panel. An educated panel in the case of architectural competitions should comprise of qualified architects themselves. However, therein lays the paradox. A competent designer judging a competent design is likely to bring his/her bias and intrigue. On the other hand, absence of such a judging entity permits ignorance to play role.
2. Personal endeavours vs. local needs and multicultural politics – A critical need is for the organisers and the participating architects to be extremely sensitive of the local issues. The same sensitivity needs to be transferred to the jury. As mentioned before, the competition provides an opportunity for architects to ponder upon issues beyond architecture, but they also present architects with an opportunity to generate narcissist proposals that are more reflective of their own portfolio rather than the demands of the program, site, and the encompassing context. Also, from an organiser’s perspective, opening up a competition to a larger audience (national or even global) is not necessarily to invite a larger talent pool but to open their markets to bring international attention.
While, marketing and discussing competitions at larger forums is encouraging, the value for extravaganza and creation of icons should be measured. We believe that Design Plus won Silvassa Institute of Higher Learning competition in 2011 essentially because of consideration to local culture, customs, festivals, plantation and climate. Annual festivals, for example, were mapped across the landscape of the campus and co-related with the potential academic year.
3. Knowledge base – This is closely tied with the above two points. A winning entry may not always be seminal. “The competition for the Palace of Nations in Geneva in 1927 is regarded as a historical error in terms of a theory of architectural judgement. The fact that the jury awarded the top prize to Nemot and Flegenheimer’s extremely conventional project – built but nevertheless absent from any of the 20th century historical surveys on architecture – is a sign of a major disciplinary controversy.
Furthermore, because the jury was unable to realise a true convergence of ethics and aesthetics, it also resolutely overlooked the modern projects of Le Corbusier, Hannes Meyer and Neutra.”4
There are always countless ground-breaking yet competition losing entries. Architecture sadly does not have the luxury of building every good idea. It is thus critical to document, catalogue, and exhibit the bright spots of each competition. These bright spots almost always seed future projects. More importantly, a rich documentation presents to the public at large, a snapshot of architecture of the era. The myriad of options generated enable public debates and reasoning.
Authors:Ar. Arun K Bij
Founder, Principal Architect, Propreitor at Design PlusAr. Abhishek Bij
Associate + Lead Designer at Design Plus Architects
1 Jean-Pierre Chupin, Carmela Cucuzzella, Bechara Helal – A world of opportunities, Architectural Competitions, Potential Architecture Book, 2015, p. 12
3 Jean-Pierre Chupin, Carmela Cucuzzella, Bechara Helal – A world of opportunities, Architectural Competitions, Potential Architecture Book, 2015, p. 13
Liked this article? Click here to consult Design Plus for your project or design dilemma.
Got some tips, design ideas? Share them with the community.
Leave a comment here or submit your own article.
Popular in this Category
A study of major changes that took place after the independence in the field of architecture in India India is ...
Low Cost Housing is a concept that deals with operative planning and techniques which reduces the cost effectively, thus making ...
The other day we were having paanipuris by the road side and at the end of our gastronomical expedition, while ...
Luxury Design Products
Wall Coverings Art
Ceramic & Tiles Ceramic & Tiles, Flooring, Interior Surfaces
An artist has no favourites, neither in choice of materials, nor in case of mediums. As an artist...
Interviews with Thought Leaders
“A built form should not be treated as a mass of brick and concrete but as a living organis...
This week we interviewed Ar Abin Chaudhuri, the young and innovative architect from the eastern p...
Tete-A-Tete with Experts
Anagram's young, multi-talented founding architects, Ar. Madhav Raman and Ar. Vaibhav Dimri h...
Architectural Case Study
No 45, Hospital Lane, Off Chatham Street, Colombo 01, Sri Lanka. Client: Georg...
No more hassles over weekend trips! No more jet lags! Weekend home is the coolest vacation mantra...
1. What is the Pritzker Prize for Architecture? The Pritzker Architecture Prize is awarded ann...
- Anu's home reflects her contemporary taste
- Mr. Sharma's Home embraces the Zen style approach
- What Ails BIM Implementation in India?
Copyright ZingyHomes - 2013 - . All rights reserved.
- Kitchen & Dining